Mustard in Middleton: A Savory Museum About a Condiment

Wall of Mustards
The museum boasts mustard from every state. Jackie Sheckler Finch photos

Wisconsin Museum Celebrates ‘Universal Condiment’ Mustard

By Jackie Sheckler Finch
GoNOMAD Senior Writer

Disappointment at a lost ballgame is what turned “a mild-mannered attorney” into the world’s leading mustard master.

Barry Levenson
Barry Levenson opened the National Mustard Museum in Middleton, Wisconsin.

“A little voice told me to do it and here I am,” Barry Levenson said, gesturing around his National Mustard Museum in Middleton, Wisconsin.

On that life-changing day in October 1986, Levenson was watching his beloved Boston Red Sox on the verge of winning the World Series. Victory seemed assured. Levenson popped a bottle of celebratory champagne.

“Then civilization as we knew it ended with Bill Buckner,” Levenson recalled. A fielding mistake by the Red Sox first baseman set up a seventh World Series game and the Red Sox lost.

Devastated by Loss.

So devastated that he couldn’t sleep, the man who grew up near Boston went to an all-night supermarket to pass the time.

Wandering the aisles in the middle of the night, Levenson told himself he should get a life, that he was crazy for letting a ballgame make him so depressed.

Then he heard a voice say, “If you collect us, they will come.”

old mustard tins
Mustard used to be sold in old fashioned tins like these.

Looking around, Levenson found himself in the condiment aisle, standing in front of the mustard section. “That’s how it all started,” he said with a grin. “That’s a true story.”

Since then, the former assistant attorney general for the State of Wisconsin has collected more than 6,300 mustards from all 50 states and more than 70 countries.

exterior of the Mustard Museum
The exterior of the Mustard Museum in Wisconsin.

“It’s a universal condiment,” he said. “And it’s been around forever. The Romans used it and Shakespeare mentioned it in four plays. He never wrote a word about that condiment-come-lately ketchup.”

Mustard Collecting Lawyer

Continuing his high-powered legal profession, Levenson also indulged in his mustard hobby. In fact, while in Washington, D.C., to argue a case before the Supreme Court, Levenson spied a mustard jar on a discarded room service tray in the hallway of his hotel.

“It was a mustard I didn’t have,” Levenson explained. “I pocketed the mustard.”

With the small jar of mustard still in his left pants pocket, Levenson argued his case before the Supreme Court. “It seemed poetic to me that the mustard should be in the court once graced by the likes of Justice Felix Frankfurter and Justice Warren Burger.”

It was a spirited argument but Levenson won Griffin v. Wisconsin, 1987.Was it his brilliant legal wrangling or the magical mustard in his pocket? Whatever the small jar of Dickinson’s mustard now has a place of honor in the growing collection.

Opening His Mustard Museum

Mrs Mustard shares a taste with a museum visitor.
Mrs Mustard shares a taste with a museum visitor.

In 1991, Levenson left his attorney job and opened the world’s first mustard museum in Mt. Horeb, Wisconsin. He moved the museum to Middleton in April of 2010 and it has been drawing mustard lovers ever since.

“If someone comes in here and says they don’t like mustard, I tell them they just haven’t tasted it yet. It’s so much more than that yellow stuff that so many people are used to,” Levenson said.

Although he no longer actively practices law, Levenson has been teaching Food Law at the University of Wisconsin Law School since 2010 and is the author of a fun book on food law, “Habeas Codfish.”

World’s Largest Collection of Mustard

Levenson’s museum is home of the world’s largest collection of mustard and mustard memorabilia, the museum has antique mustard pots, tins and vintage advertisements.

Levenson said he looks at mustard as “a metaphor. It’s something small we take for granted. But when you start to examine it, you see the wonders and the history beneath.”

According to archaeologists and botanists, mustard seeds have been found in Stone Age settlements. Archaeological evidence suggests that the ancient Egyptians also flavored food with mustard, as shown by mustard seeds found in the tomb of Tutankhamun.

Poupon U hoodieOne of the museum’s most valuable artifacts is the King’s Mustard Pot – a rare official souvenir celebrating the visit to Canada in 1939 of England’s King George VI and his wife Elizabeth.

“King George was the subject of the movie ‘The King’s Speech,’ the story of young Prince Albert (Bertie) and his struggles to overcome debilitating stammering,” Levenson said.

Poupon U. Degrees

The museum is also home to Poupon U. with its official cheer: “Who needs Harvard, who needs Yale? At Poupon U, you’ll never fail!”

Visitors can buy Poupon U. degrees – including “Doctor of Diddley Squat” and “Juris Dufus” – as well as sweatshirts, mugs, and even a toilet seat with the university’s yellow mustard pot seal.

Other museum highlights include the world’s only mustard vending machine (where visitors can actually buy a jar of mustard), and the Great Wall of Mustard with mustards from every state.

Visit MustardPiece Theatre where you can hear the history of the condiment, gift shop, tasting bar and Mrs. Mustard’s Kitchen where you can learn how to spice up your cooking with mustard.

And, yes, there really is a Mrs. Mustard.Married since 1996, Levenson and his wife Patti met at a mustard tasting.

“It was love at first squeeze,” he joked. “We’re having the time of our lives.”birth of taste

For more information: Contact the National Mustard Museum at (800) 438-6878, or the Wisconsin Department of Tourism at (800) 432-8747,

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Latest posts by Jackie Finch (see all)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top
Skip to content