Skip to content

Annie Elle

Annie Elle

Annie Elle is originally from Los Angeles but has lived and worked abroad since 2011. She is currently living in Douala, Cameroon, working in international education. She loves discovering new fruits, learning different board games, and taking Afrostep dance classes.

1 Comment

  1. Nahren Anweya
    April 19, 2026 @ 5:07 am

    Dear Annie,

    Thank you for your article and for highlighting the historical and cultural significance of the region. I would respectfully suggest a few important clarifications to ensure the historical record is presented with greater accuracy and balance.

    First, regarding Rabban Hormizd Monastery, it is important to recognize that the monastery was not originally “Chaldean” in the modern denominational sense. Founded in the 7th century, it functioned for centuries as a central monastic and patriarchal seat of the Assyrian Church of the East, specifically associated with the Eliya patriarchal line. Only after the ecclesiastical divisions that began in the mid-16th century did parts of this tradition enter communion with Rome, eventually forming what is now known as the Chaldean Catholic Church. Referring to Rabban Hormizd as “Chaldean” from its origins unintentionally obscures its foundational role within the Assyrian Church of the East and the broader continuity of East Syriac Christianity.

    Second, the historical development of the term “Chaldean” itself deserves careful framing. Following the 1552 schism associated with Yohannan Sulaqa, segments of the Church of the East entered communion with Rome. Over time, the term “Chaldean” came to be applied to these Catholic communities. Many Assyrians therefore understand “Chaldean” primarily as an ecclesiastical designation rather than a distinct ethnic origin, reflecting continuity within a broader Assyrian heritage, even as identity terminology remains a subject of discussion today.

    Finally, any historical account of northern Mesopotamia should acknowledge the profound impact of the Seyfo. During World War I, Assyrian Christians were subjected to mass killings, displacement, and destruction under Ottoman rule nearly wiping out 75% of all Assyrians. These atrocities were carried out by Ottoman authorities and, in many regions, with the participation of local tribal forces, including many Kurdish groups and leadership. The consequences of Seyfo were devastating, contributing to the depopulation and long-term marginalization of Assyrian Christian communities in their ancestral homeland. Imagine the Nazi’s committing a holocaust and no one would have came to save the day. Unfortunately, what you saw is the aftermath of nearly wiping out the world’s oldest Christian’s.

    Assyrians are widely recognized as an indigenous people of Mesopotamia, with a continuous cultural and historical presence spanning millennia. Any portrayal of the region benefits from acknowledging both this deep-rooted heritage and the historical traumas that have shaped its present reality. This year was the Assyrian 6,776 new year on April 1st.

    My intention in sharing these points is not to detract from your work, but to help ensure that the history of this region—particularly the legacy of the Church of the East and the experiences of Assyrian Christians—is represented as fully and accurately as possible.

    Thank you again for your thoughtful coverage, and I appreciate your consideration of these perspectives.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *