Wednesday, March 29, 2006

The World is Round says Laurence Prusak

I have not yet read 'The World is Flat' by Thomas Friedman. My brother-in-law has a copy and all I have to do is to borrow it. I am not at all sold out to the idea that world has become flat. Why? Laurence Prusak says it beautifully through this HBS article:

Yes, we are interconnected on a truly astonishing scale. But Gates, Friedman, and many others make a fundamental error when they argue that brute connectivity will level the playing field, giving that twentysomething in Shanghai the ability to compete head-to-head with anyone, anywhere in the world. Their mistake is that they’re confusing information with knowledge.

This isn’t a new idea. College professors have forever struggled with students’ efforts to pass off the former as the latter. But consultants, journalists, and businesspeople have dangerously blurred the distinction as they’ve championed trillions of dollars worth of IT purchases made with the intention of “managing knowledge.” For the most part, what we’ve built is a vast global IT infrastructure that is very good at moving information, but not knowledge, from one place to another.

Have a look at the article.

This is what I had said when HBS invited reader's comments on the level playing field or the flat world:

I wonder if it is more meaningful to address the question "What is a Level Playing Field?" to:

A person who doesn't have roof over his or her head.

A person who has to force his or her children into child labor to make ends meet.

A person who has gone hungry tonight or does not know where his or her next meal is going to come from.

Someone in a village where there is no electricity, roads, or even a school.

And then, probably, we should wonder what we are doing to create a level playing field for them or even if it is a priority.

You can see the reader's comments in full here.

2 Comments:

Blogger Crystal said...

I read the article and comments, and your points sum up my feelings about whether or not the whole internet/information revolution has really changed the world. In some aspects, YES it has made everything more accessible, and internet cafes proliferate in even the poorest of poor nations so these people in theory do have acess to more information about the outside world. But definitely there is still no "level playing field" nor will there ever be one. Human beings are really statified and hierarchy prevails in all societies, so the world is never gonna be an equal playing field. I believe that life is getting better globally for most people, but of course there is still a LONG way to go towards ending world poverty et al.

1:59 AM  
Blogger Mridula said...

I too wonder Crystal, if there will ever be a level playing field. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

3:31 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

© Mridula 2005-2008 | Design By

  • The Glass Palace